Review of Chinatown

Chinatown (1974)
7/10
Quite good, but over-rated seems like......
17 May 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Well, having bought the DVD of this lately, I finally sat myself down and watched Chinatown w/out any commercials. Thank you AMC. Anyways-just what exactly was this 'JaaaaCK' movie/throw-back to the '40's noir flix all about? Why is it praised to the high heavens? Got me.

Here's what's good: *Jack Nicholson. Reins in his scenery chewing and gives a terrific, focused performance ala Bogie or Mitchum. I liked this a lot.

*Stylish camera-work, period detail, etc. Polanski nails it.

*Supporting work by Lopez, Huston, Dunaway and Burt Young, all fine. Huston is clearly a scary SOB no doubting it.

*Involving plot, and Towne was right--water rights and reservoirs aren't quite the same as Maltese Falcons--they're believable and mean huge $$ to those who can corner the market.

*Downbeat ending. Yah sometimes the baddies win.

What's not so good: *Quite slow. This has that '70's d-r-a-g things o-u-t pace, you do wish they'd hurry parts of it along some.

*Polanski and his knife cameo. Like bad Joe Pesci. C'mon guys.

*Hated seeing Faye get shot.

*Dull sorta film overall. You sit and wait for something to happen, and besides a few fights or near drownings, nothing much does for long periods of time save for Jack being...Jaaaaack.

Overall--***1/2 outta ****, Godfather Too was better, but the Conversation, that was the best for '74.
20 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed