6/10
entertaining though not especially memorable
3 February 2006
This is a decent film though there's really nothing about it that makes it especially memorable. I think this is made worse by the fact that the film stars Gregory Peck and he went on to make MANY better westerns. This one just seems pretty pedestrian.

The movie is a combination of a B-style western about the cavalry and THE DIRTY DOZEN, as Peck is in charge of a small detail of misfit soldiers who are trying to stem off a major Indian attack. The problem is that despite SOME similarities to THE DIRTY DOZEN, the writing just isn't that good at times and the reasoning why Peck took this group of degenerates on the mission seems really stupid--I mean putting the safety of everyone back home in the hands of people who only cared about saving their sorry butts. In reality, such a group would have either deserted or shot their C.O. and then deserted.
6 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed