The storyline is compelling, the acting; very good, the direction; impressive, the only problem I have with this film is in the character of Sandra Bullock's, Ellen Roark. Her part was pathetically overwritten. If this was intentional to secure the interests of Ms. Bullock, then this is the movie's failing. I have nothing against Ms. Bullock as an actor, I have enjoyed her performances in numerous roles, however this happens to not be one of them. She is almost a comic book caricature of herself and it detracts from the impact of the story immensely. She professes to be a student of law, yet at many twists and turns she appears to be more knowledgeable of the law than her counterpart, the lead counselor for the defense (Matthew McConaughey), a bona fide licensed, practicing attorney. She also appears to possess a degree in medicine based on a scene where a simple "band aid" would seem counter-indicative considering the nature, source and force of the injury she simply 'dresses'.
The closing argument (summation scene) is very emotional and should win this movie critical acclaim based on that merit alone, although this is somewhat jaded by some of the unrealistic, outlandish events which precede it and therefore merely lend toward relegating this film to cinematic mediocrity. It appears to be a bit melodramatic in some places and Donald Sutherland's role is weak, underdeveloped and unimpressive (pity because I really like Mr. Sutherland as an actor). All in all, it's definitely worth the watch for the compelling storyline, if nothing else, about racial injustice, but if you happen to miss it, you won't regret too much. Matthew McConaughey is excellent in his role as the inexperienced, though passionate, lead defense attorney and deserves all due praise.
The closing argument (summation scene) is very emotional and should win this movie critical acclaim based on that merit alone, although this is somewhat jaded by some of the unrealistic, outlandish events which precede it and therefore merely lend toward relegating this film to cinematic mediocrity. It appears to be a bit melodramatic in some places and Donald Sutherland's role is weak, underdeveloped and unimpressive (pity because I really like Mr. Sutherland as an actor). All in all, it's definitely worth the watch for the compelling storyline, if nothing else, about racial injustice, but if you happen to miss it, you won't regret too much. Matthew McConaughey is excellent in his role as the inexperienced, though passionate, lead defense attorney and deserves all due praise.