Despite some reviews to the contrary, I would have to say that this is arguably Esther Williams' best movie, along with Bathing Beauty. Your enjoyment of it may depend on whether you like Peter Lawford as Esther's love interest and how you react to what he does. It may seem a bit contrived and/or unrealistic, but, I don't think you're supposed to be thinking a lot anyway. Jimmy Durante is on hand to perform some of his best work. Ricardo Montalban and Cyd Charisse make a very believable couple and have several very memorable and sensuous dance numbers; they almost seem more suited than Esther and Ricardo in "Neptune's Daughter." If you want to be alone with these good-looking people and Jimmy, this is where you want to be: on an island with Esther.
Review of On an Island with You
