When I first read "A Murder is Announced" I was underwhelmed, considering it one of the weaker of Christie's mysteries. The plot just seems far too convoluted to be believable. However, watching this film helps you forget how needlessly elaborate the murder plot is as you get caught up in the excellent performances. Zoe Wanamaker's performance is, in particular, very memorable. (Some spoilers to follow).
I must comment on the death scene of Ms. Murgatroyd. It is a powerful scene and I felt quite affected at the grief-stricken reaction of Geraldine McEwen's Miss Marple. But upon reflection, I believe it is out of character. Miss Marple's effectiveness as a detective was due in part to her calm acceptance of the reality of evil in the world and her ability to be somewhat emotionally removed from the events that transpired around her. Miss Marple would have been distressed by the death and moved to grim action but I don't think she would have been reduced to paroxysms of sorrow even by the death of someone she cared about. For what I believe to be a more accurate portrayal, view the filmed version of this novel starring Joan Hickson. I thought her a little too stern to be Miss Marple initially but have revised my opinion.
Both versions of this novel are worth watching!
I must comment on the death scene of Ms. Murgatroyd. It is a powerful scene and I felt quite affected at the grief-stricken reaction of Geraldine McEwen's Miss Marple. But upon reflection, I believe it is out of character. Miss Marple's effectiveness as a detective was due in part to her calm acceptance of the reality of evil in the world and her ability to be somewhat emotionally removed from the events that transpired around her. Miss Marple would have been distressed by the death and moved to grim action but I don't think she would have been reduced to paroxysms of sorrow even by the death of someone she cared about. For what I believe to be a more accurate portrayal, view the filmed version of this novel starring Joan Hickson. I thought her a little too stern to be Miss Marple initially but have revised my opinion.
Both versions of this novel are worth watching!