4/10
Oh my goodness...I must be an old cynic...
17 July 2012
I found this film unbearably corny and dated, even for the period. Norma Shearer never impressed me when she played any sort of a period or costume role, as she became too self-aware and phony. Some actresses, Garbo for one, could slip in and out of costume dramas and more modern roles with believability, but not Norma. The only times I found her to be natural were in her early roles as a young actress when she wasn't playing Mrs. Thalberg.

This one was just a little too old-fashioned and sentimental for my tastes. I had hoped for more, for a pre-code film.

Leslie Howard is generally good in anything he does, and he performs well enough here. But I don't feel a whole lot of chemistry between the pair. And maybe it is the black and white format, but in the portions where Norma is in the blond role, her hair looks more gray than blond, which ages her.

I guess I am not a softy...sorry, I don't mean to be harsh, but just did not like this one very much.
6 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed