Review of The Scarf

The Scarf (1951)
7/10
flawed but intriguing
28 January 2017
I liked this movie.

Having seen my share of hogwash from this period of American filmmaking, I can say that the movie kept me interested, which I can't say for a lot of the dreck from this period.

We are constantly kept wondering who this escaped, supposedly insane, criminal is, and that question is what sustains our curiosity throughout the movie.

There is a certain amount of philosophizing in the script, but it never rises to an arcane level, nor does it interfere with plot development.

Casting is excellent. John Ireland is a very capable and underrated character actor. The star of the show is definitely James Barton as the hermit turkey farmer. You can't take your eyes of him, and he is the linchpin. Mercedes McCambridge shines as the loose woman with a heart of gold, and she is an excellent singer.

My caveat is with the convoluted finish, with too many plot threads wrapped up in an unconvincing and contrived manner. However, the first three quarters of the movie is good enough to carry us through to the weak ending.

It's worth a watch.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed