This episode has plenty of strong components but also some glaring weaknesses. The weaknesses are tied up with the villains - - rock creatures created with bad cgi and basic campy Roman ruler antagonist. Also, defeated with a water pistol? Funny but dumb.
The strengths of this episode once again lies in its characters. Peter Capaldi gives an outstanding pre-Doctor performance as a marble tradesmen/caring father. Donna really keeps this episode grounded and human. Not just funny, she proves to be just what the Doctor needs, someone to defy him and remind him what is right.
This episode centers around the struggle between not interfering with history and compassion for others. A theme often repeated throughout the fourth season, and a defining struggle for the Doctor. And it shines in the portrayal of this struggle. Unfortunately the camp and lackluster villains brings it down a notch. 8/10
The strengths of this episode once again lies in its characters. Peter Capaldi gives an outstanding pre-Doctor performance as a marble tradesmen/caring father. Donna really keeps this episode grounded and human. Not just funny, she proves to be just what the Doctor needs, someone to defy him and remind him what is right.
This episode centers around the struggle between not interfering with history and compassion for others. A theme often repeated throughout the fourth season, and a defining struggle for the Doctor. And it shines in the portrayal of this struggle. Unfortunately the camp and lackluster villains brings it down a notch. 8/10