Following up from the smash-hit that was 'Until Dawn', Supermassive Games turned to the independent route and created their own "make your own path" horror game franchise, commencing with this very game. However, Until Dawn is the best and worst thing for this game - best as it simply wouldn't exist without Until Dawn but worst as it led everyone to wrong expectations, everyone expected another slasher story but that's not what this is - this is a ghost story.
The plot of the game is somewhat well-crafted as dives into interesting themes such as: paranoia and disenfranchisement of cultures following WW2, however the ambitious over-focus on alternating pathways with no thought of plot armour for specific characters in certain situations (which allowed Until Dawn to have a naturally flowing plot/pace no matter what you've chosen) is gone now - often leading the ending chapters of the game, especially the epilogue, to feel rushed, clumsy and unfinished. The big plot twist simply does the game no big favours, while it is clear what they were trying to aim thematically (with it presumably being a metaphor for how we create our own fears of a past we didn't witness), it simply doesn't work as good as just having a traditional ghost story would have done for this plot. It is also worth noting that despite there being so many ways for the lead protagonists to die, the actual feeling of trying to make the characters survive the night is gone as the game makes it really easy for the player to save them all.
However, on a gameplay aspect, I have no huge quarrels with the game apart from the fixed angle perspectives making it occasionally difficult to navigate your way through the ship. The character models and environments are all beautifully designed, perfectly convey accuracy while creating a perfect atmosphere for the game, the ship literally feeling dead and lifeless which is very apt, as well as some eye-catching aesthetics. Sadly, the facial motions of the character models are nothing to write home about as they are often very hit-or-miss which doesn't compliment the actually decent voice acting on display.
Overall, Man of Medan is a decent launching pad for the franchise and while the it isn't Supermassive Games' strongest, it is an enjoyable experience nevertheless.
The plot of the game is somewhat well-crafted as dives into interesting themes such as: paranoia and disenfranchisement of cultures following WW2, however the ambitious over-focus on alternating pathways with no thought of plot armour for specific characters in certain situations (which allowed Until Dawn to have a naturally flowing plot/pace no matter what you've chosen) is gone now - often leading the ending chapters of the game, especially the epilogue, to feel rushed, clumsy and unfinished. The big plot twist simply does the game no big favours, while it is clear what they were trying to aim thematically (with it presumably being a metaphor for how we create our own fears of a past we didn't witness), it simply doesn't work as good as just having a traditional ghost story would have done for this plot. It is also worth noting that despite there being so many ways for the lead protagonists to die, the actual feeling of trying to make the characters survive the night is gone as the game makes it really easy for the player to save them all.
However, on a gameplay aspect, I have no huge quarrels with the game apart from the fixed angle perspectives making it occasionally difficult to navigate your way through the ship. The character models and environments are all beautifully designed, perfectly convey accuracy while creating a perfect atmosphere for the game, the ship literally feeling dead and lifeless which is very apt, as well as some eye-catching aesthetics. Sadly, the facial motions of the character models are nothing to write home about as they are often very hit-or-miss which doesn't compliment the actually decent voice acting on display.
Overall, Man of Medan is a decent launching pad for the franchise and while the it isn't Supermassive Games' strongest, it is an enjoyable experience nevertheless.