Review of Walk of Punishment

Soundtrack : (9/10) Dialogue : (9.4/10) Story : (9.6/10) Cinematography : (9.1/10) Character Development : (9.4/10) Conflict : (9.5/10) Excitement : (9/10) Reasonableness : (9.5/10) Overall : (9.3/10)

Pros :

• the beginning of the episode is a 10/10 as we see the funeral and proceeding with a solid scene between Robb, Blackfish, and Edmure.

• a great acting, emotional scene from Catelyn as she griefs for her children

• the council scene is an S tier scene. I love how Tyrion slowly takes a chair and sits in the opposite side from Tywin as if he is testing their patience.

-a great "goodbye" scene as Arya leaves Hotpie

• Ramsey frees Theon and the chase was amazing and the editing and the direction was great.

• The argument between Jorah and Barristan Selmy was a highlight with great dialogue and reasoning for everyone's perspective.

• the ending showed us the honorable side of Jaimie with contrast of first season's Jaimie. This is certainly a great change in Jaimie's arc as he lost his most valuable thing the represents his character.

Cons :

• the scene with the nights watch in Craster's keep was a bit dull but still good considering the lack of interesting conflict in there and personally I'm not interested in Sam and Gilly relationship.

• Stannis and Melisandre's scene was the worst scene in this episode and that doesn't mean it was bad, it means that there wasn't enough context to make the scene a stand up scene.