The first two seasons of this show, featuring Carolyn Quentin as Maddie Magellan, are just about perfect -- a combination of absurd humor and intriguing "impossible" crimes. The character of Adam Klaus as a oversexed, narcissistic Vegas style magician is also hilarious, even with a change in actors over two seasons. The solutions to the crimes are intriguing, and even when they are a bit over-the-top, they are still good entertainment. The not-quite romantic relationship between Creek and Magellan doesn't always make sense, but they have a quirky chemistry and their ups and downs make for some good comedy.
Seasons 3-5, without the Magellan character, are not quite as strong. There is a weird love-triangle in seasons 3-4 involving Jonathan Creek, an old flame, and her husband, who is not at all jealous of the two of them and admits to having been briefly gay. It's odd but not funny--just awkward. There are still some very funny moments, e.g. An episode in which a woman whose pet dog has died starts to date Jonathan Creek but goes for walks with him, plays fetch with him, and generally uses him as a dog-substitute.
In season 5, Creek gives up his frumpy magician assistant persona and becomes a suit-wearing executive in The City. He has an attractive but drearily respectable wife who detests his interest in magic and crime-solving. This new conformity doesn't fit his character at all and the marriage seems unlikely--it's hard to believe the two would get past a first date.. The crimes become increasingly farfetched, though there is still some amusing dialogue and wordplay.
As a whole, the series isn't without flaws--it did go downhill after Carolyn Quentin left, especially in the final season. But the first two seasons were so strong, they outweigh the weak points of what followed. Even the worst episodes of this series are better than most current viewing options..
Seasons 3-5, without the Magellan character, are not quite as strong. There is a weird love-triangle in seasons 3-4 involving Jonathan Creek, an old flame, and her husband, who is not at all jealous of the two of them and admits to having been briefly gay. It's odd but not funny--just awkward. There are still some very funny moments, e.g. An episode in which a woman whose pet dog has died starts to date Jonathan Creek but goes for walks with him, plays fetch with him, and generally uses him as a dog-substitute.
In season 5, Creek gives up his frumpy magician assistant persona and becomes a suit-wearing executive in The City. He has an attractive but drearily respectable wife who detests his interest in magic and crime-solving. This new conformity doesn't fit his character at all and the marriage seems unlikely--it's hard to believe the two would get past a first date.. The crimes become increasingly farfetched, though there is still some amusing dialogue and wordplay.
As a whole, the series isn't without flaws--it did go downhill after Carolyn Quentin left, especially in the final season. But the first two seasons were so strong, they outweigh the weak points of what followed. Even the worst episodes of this series are better than most current viewing options..