6/10
It's unbelievable that at this point, the writers have created such an unnecessary subplot that leads nowhere
14 May 2024
Genet begins a search for Laurent, seeking to eliminate him as he is a symbol of hope to people. As part of this, Genet makes a deal with Quinn who seeks Laurent in order to get Isabelle back. After escaping from a flooded building, and having a dream that a praying Laurent is ignored by a mob of walkers, Daryl encounters Antoine who is killed by guerriers, but he helps the dying man to free his pigeons. Reuniting with Isabelle, Daryl tracks Laurent to the ruins of the Eiffel Tower where the boy nearly falls victim to a herd. During the rescue, Laurent is kidnapped by Quinn's men and taken to Demimonde. With the help of a captive, whom he tortures and later abandons to walkers, Daryl sneaks into the nightclub and rescues Laurent while Fallou and his people create a distraction. Daryl overpowers Quinn while Anna, disgruntled by Quinn's obsession with Isabelle, lets them go. Having fallen in love with Emile, Sylvie decides to stay in Paris with him while Isabelle decides to stay in order to get Quinn to help secure Daryl and Laurent passage out as Genet locks the city down. Daryl and Laurent leave Paris on a boat heading to the Nest, the Union's main base.

The first three episodes presented us with a France devastated by the apocalypse, and the hope that everything can change. The next three episodes (including this one) are moving towards concluding the plot and leaving doors open for the next season. Here, the series' narrative has completely stagnated, and nothing relevant is presented to us, except for a few uninteresting action sequences. The script's standstill is evident, as at the end of the previous episode Daryl falls, giving the idea that we would have a minimally interesting episode start, which in fact does not happen. This shows that the episode moves in a lost and anticlimactic way throughout, with completely disposable scenes without any dramatic effect.

The initial sequence of the episode was somewhat intriguing because, even though it was a hallucination, seeing the boy in a risky situation may have made Daryl more protective of the child. In addition, all this belief around Laurent about him being the hope is being very well developed in various aspects, both in dialogues, actions, flashbacks, and now hallucinations. Here we also have the focus of Genet's group discovering that there really is a boy that people believe is the hope of everything, and she seems to mock because with the existence of this boy, the people of the Union of Hope would be blinded and would not follow what she wants to preach. As shown in one of the previous trailers, it seems that the series will still show this authoritarian and ultranationalist side of the character, drawing parallels with other real figures who are seen as villains of humanity.

Finally, Laurent manages to reach the Eiffel Tower, a symbolic place for him, as it is where his mother's photo is located. The scene suggests that those walkers have been trapped there for a long time, and when Laurent arrives and they manage to break down the barrier, it seemed a bit too forced. But anyway, Daryl and Isabelle arrive to save the boy, until he is kidnapped, and the series creates a new subplot. The protagonists manage to capture a member of the group that took Laurent and try to extract some information. Daryl's coldness in stabbing the enemy's abdomen with a sharp object is agonizing to watch, but it is satisfying from the perspective of the character's evolution in this spin-off, which in this particular scene reminded me of Negan, being sarcastic in a brutal moment.

It's unbelievable that at this point, the writers have created such an unnecessary subplot that leads nowhere. The boy is taken to Quinn's nightclub, and everything indicates that he only kidnaps the boy to get to Isabelle. Daryl manages to invade the nightclub, and the two characters fight, with the protagonist winning and Quinn being knocked unconscious. It seems that there is no more room for the character in the plot, so I believe that in the final two episodes, the series will not focus on him again. The characters meet near a river, and Isabelle decides to stay and send Daryl and Laurent by boat. This point was a bit confusing for many people, but since Genet has surrounded the entire city, Isabelle believes that if the group separates, it becomes more difficult to be caught, and Daryl to protect Laurent seems like the best option. However, with only the two of them alone, they become more vulnerable to Genet and Codron's attacks.

Speaking of the boy, it is still difficult to delineate what exactly the series wants to represent with his character. Obviously, the messianic traits exist, but it is noticeable that both the direction and the script cannot bring a necessarily believable or curious approach to the theme. There is nothing truly symbolic, except perhaps for that scene where Daryl dreams of the boy praying and warding off zombies (which leads nowhere, by the way), nor is there anything critical or minimally provocative/reflective about the insinuations of religion and faith in most of the dialogues. Is this boy supposed to be a symbol of hope? Why exactly? And where is the dramatic substance or any kind of thematic, narrative, or symbolic representation around it? It seems that the story wants us to buy into this idea with a few lines of dialogue about innocence and childlike purity as justification.

Even worse than that is the absolute laziness in several scenes of the episode. Apparently, Daryl was bitten in the water and even appears limping afterward, but this is left hanging... in a mix of careless mystery with random insinuation. We also have the terribly directed sequence of Laurent being kidnapped - what was that shot of Daryl letting go of the boy's car? Or the completely emotionless farewell of Isabelle and that other former nun who is overflowing with libido. The season has gradually become a collage of arbitrary moments, something that makes me look less favorably at the concepts I praised in the pilot, like the medieval side or the religious aspects that haven't amounted to anything so far. Notice, for example, the torture scene and the almost trial-like indication of Isabelle, opening up space for a discussion of morality and violence that the franchise has already addressed, but that simply dissipates...

"La Dame de Fer" is a slow and weak episode that leads nowhere. The series, which came from an excellent sequence in the last three episodes, completely loses its way here. With the resumption of the main mission at the end of this episode and two episodes remaining, the series has everything to deliver great moments and make us forget about this fourth episode. The series started with some minimally curious and unusual ideas for the franchise, but as the episodes have progressed, it is noticeable that there is no cohesion or deepening in the concepts and themes presented or insinuated by the narrative. It's all up in the air, maintaining the same dramatic problems of the franchise (bad dialogues, melodrama) and also those of direction (lack of tension, zero visual creativity for staging or setting, no scope), in addition to this growing sense of randomness that I have felt in the last episodes.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed