Gwen gives her high school boyfriend a job, but Terry quickly discovers he's inept. Danny attempts to write an article about Guy for a bartender's magazine, but he finds the only interesting about Guy is that he's a total mystery.
While volunteering at the church, Terry finds herself tempting three hunky seminary students. Meanwhile, Gwen convinces Guy to help her cheat the church's thrift store out of designer clothes.
After mistakenly giving Mr. Lux a rent check from their business account, Terry dreams she and her friends are in an episode of "Mission: Impossible," attempting to get the check back.
Gwen makes Mickey wait until their fifth date to have sex, but complications arise (or rather, don't). Meanwhile, Terry and Danny enter a writing competition and discover they have vastly different memories of the same childhood event.
While Gwen's vacationing with her boyfriend, Terry's recently divorced friend Debbie sleeps over... in Danny's bed. Meanwhile, Ashley's upcoming audition for a straight role leads him to recruit Guy and Danny to teach him how to act manly.
Terry reluctantly goes out with Steve, then enlists Gwen to help her break up with him. Meanwhile, Guy and Danny use found money to score Knicks tickets.