User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
The More Things Change...
boblipton7 April 2006
Eddie Barry wants to keep wife Betty Compson happy, and she wants him to be a race car driver, so he hires a driver to impersonate himself on the track; but there is an accident and he has to go to the hospital and convince the doctor to have him bandaged. He persuades him to do so by offering to donate $2000 to the hospital -- this made me blink: not at the thought of bribing a doctor with money, but at how cheap it was; or perhaps it simply indicates how far the dollar has fallen in ninety years. When Betty shows up at the hospital, she quickly discovers the deception and is angered by it, but forgives her husband when she is shown how badly injured the actual driver was. It might have been her husband. Finish.

Most of the humor comes from the men literally slapping their thighs in joy at the thought of the deception and the ending device, which comes off as rather abrupt.

What I find interesting about this movie is that it looks like it was a Biograph shot about five years earlier by Griffith. Its compositions are standard Biograph compositions, even to the defining right wall. I can't find any reference to who the cameraman was, but director Christie had been making movies for eight years at this point, for Nestor, which was the first production company with permanent facilities in greater Los Angeles. The overwhelming influence of Griffith at this point cannot be appreciated by a modern audience -- it's as if, after James Cameron made TITANIC, no one ever made a movie for less than $300,000,000 ever again.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Trifling Short Comedy
FerdinandVonGalitzien12 April 2007
Herr Al Christie was a prolific film director who made a lot of trifling short comedies during the early silent times for the ephemeral glory of ordinary actors who starred in the majority of those productions, namely the comedy team Eddie Lyons & Lee Moran and Dame Betty Compson who is the lustreless star of "As Luck Would Have It". For these reasons, this German aristocrat could say that Herr Al Christie was a kind of early and significant pioneer director of silent B pictures.

"As Luck Would Have It" is a good example of Herr Al Christie typical films: simple history, poor performances and scarce technical improvements although in this case the film includes some outer shots of racing cars for the joy of the longhaired audience.

The plot besides being simplistic and humourless is ordinary for this German Count; in order to be in fashion, Dame Compson wants to be a nurse during the old WWI times; not to mention that she also wants her husband to be an ambulance driver too or something like that ( besides ordinary, Dame Compson's character is a little dim too) so it would be better that he starts to begin training as a race car driver.

The Dame Compson's character stupidity leads her to believe, and she proclaims this without shame, that maybe thanks to her husband's merits "they will make him a Duke or something'"… MEIN GOTT!!... so easy she thinks that it is to achieve a title of nobility even in Amerika??!!!.. if perhaps he was driving an elegant Hispano-Suizo but an ordinary race car??...

It is evident that this film is disrespectful to the aristocracy, not to mention its boldness to laugh at WWI in such ordinary way, enough demerits for this German Count to call for an urgent meeting to begin legal or illegal procedures to arrest this director wherever he is.

And now, if you'll allow me, I must temporarily take my leave because this German Count must discuss with his advocates their nonexistent wages.

Herr Graf Ferdinand Von Galitzien http://ferdinandvongalitzien.blogspot.com/
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed