User Reviews

I think this is a really excellent little short. Great acting from the three kids. Funny, characterful, but not too over the top. It's very well scripted with some nice surprises. I love some of the long tracking shots, particularly the scene in the loo, and also the final shot, both must have required loads of rehearsal, and the timing is flawless. I also really like the grading and colour saturation which gives it a kind of old retro 70's feel adding to the whole gangster satire look.

My only concern is that some of the accents are so strong that a US audience might not be able to follow it at all, but hey that's their loss! Top short overall.

As far back as he could remember, schoolboy Michael has always wanted to be a gangster. When he and his friends get jobs delivering free newspapers they quickly tire of it until they decide to dump the papers and claim they are delivering them. Michael has his eyes on the beautiful Ann-Marie and wants the money to impress her and win her over, while Bobby and Michael just want money for sweets. Either way they build on their newspaper racket, getting more cash until the point where things come to a head.

From the opening scene, with the mock Scottish accents this is an obvious spoof on Goodfellas that has some value in being the only full spoof of that film I know of, but not enough merit on its own to really be worth hunting out. When Michael is slapped for talking to himself when he says the 'as far back' line, I thought the film would then step back and be more of its own beast, but it doesn't, it keeps to the mould of the first scene and is full of very direct copies of Goodfellas scenes with only the idea of it being with Scottish schoolboys being the source of humour. It has its own plot of course but it feels like this is forced into setting up the spoofs rather than being written first.

Personally I love the TV show Spaced, full of spoofs and references galore but there they are done with invention and wit, within the frame of a story – so that the references are not the whole ball game. With Wise Guys this wit is lacking and at times it just feels like it is taking the obvious choices. The cast don't do much to help because they have nothing to really work with other than aping the performances in the movie. The kids are OK I guess but did we really need some of them (Quinn in particular) to talk in forced 'Noo Yark' accents? Lorraine McIntosh of Deacon Blue fame makes a brief appearance as well.

Overall this is amusing but it takes all the easy options and forgets to have its own ideas or wit. With only spoof copies of key Goodfella's scenes, the film begins to run out of steam before it has reached the end (it is really the same gag over and over again) even though it is only 10 minutes long. Nice idea but badly set up, missing the laughs that a lighter touch or more subtle spoof (homage?) would have had.

...nice more for accent than for developement of basic idea. Because it is not different by many others films with same theme. The mix of humor and adventure, the nice young men, the bizarre adults, the dream and the end of succesful bussiness. And, in essence, nothing more. Only the seductive short film reminding the others in the genre of Emil and detectives.