"Alfred Hitchcock Presents" Miss Bracegirdle Does Her Duty (TV Episode 1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
It's hard to believe it isn't better given the plot idea.
planktonrules31 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Mildred Natwick plays a woman who has lived a sheltered life in Britain. Oddly, she suddenly decides in her middle age to go to Paris where she ends up having a surprising adventure...an adventure in the hotel in which she stays. It all begins after she takes a bath and like in many older hotels, the bathroom is not connected to the hotel room. When she returns to her room, she makes the mistake of entering the wrong room...a room in which a dead man is lying in bed!! And, to make it worse (and contrived) the door knob falls off and she's stuck with the dead guy. What's next? See the show.

While the outline sounds really neat, the show isn't. There really is no interesting twist at the end and the show was very dull despite the plot idea. Worth seeing, perhaps, but far from a must-see episode of "Alfred Hitchcock Presents".
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I didn't really find the episode light hearted tbh
glitterrose12 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Something tells me this might be an episode that you might find the viewers divided. Some might find the episode boring because all Miss Bracegirdle does in this episode is worry herself to death. Or you might have some people that might find Miss Bracegirdle funny because of the peculiar way she acts.

I'm somebody that didn't find the episode boring or funny. It was an interesting story but unfortunately I can relate to Miss Bracegirdles worrying nature. Although I'll say Miss Bracegirdle does have some strength. She took this trip to Paris all by herself. That's a pretty brave/big move for somebody that probably never left the area she was born at. Doesn't matter if she's doing it because she's doing her duty or not. Fact is she did it.

But Miss Bracegirdle has a few difficulties thrown at her. She arrives at the hotel she's staying at and she wants to take a bath. She takes her bath but she gets lost on her way back to her room. She ends up in the room with a man that's a total stranger! Even worse, a part broke off the door knob and she's locked in. She's embarrassed and absolutely horrified at all this. Several scenes show her debating herself on what to do. One scene had the woman so nervous about this that she ends up under the man's bed. She eventually comes out from under the bed and decides to just wake the sleeping man up. New problem: the man isn't asleep, he's dead. Miss Bracegirdle panics some more. She's got to get out of this room! She sees some sealing wax and she starts to melt some so she can see if she can pull that piece of the door knob closer to her so she can attach the door knob again and get out. The poor lady sat there for hours but she managed to get it done.

She rushed back to her room and that's when she panics again. She'll have to go back to that man's room in order to get back her personal belongings that she left behind. She goes back and gets her things and picks up the stuff she used in order to get the doorknob back working.

It's morning and the hotel staff are serving tea or coffee to people. A lady comes into Miss Bracegirdle's room and she confides to Miss Bracegirdle about the man being dead in the nearby room. But there's more to the story than that! This deceased man was a killer! The lady goes back out and Miss Bracegirdle's horrified when a male hotel employee comes into her room. She was fully dressed in her night clothes but she still makes a mad dash to the bed so she can cover herself up more. The guy ends up pulling a stocking Miss Bracegirdle left behind and winking at Miss Bracegirdle, almost as if to say 'You're secret's safe with me.'
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Mild Comedy of Manners
dougdoepke25 December 2010
Hard to resist an amusing title like this. The result, unfortunately, is only mildly amusing with a dollop of suspense thrown in. As her name suggests, Miss Bracegirdle is a very, very proper English lady in the early 1900's. That opening scene says it all, with the very proper afternoon tea and the sheltered ladies fretting over middle-aged Bracegirdle's coming trip to libertine France. How will she manage among the strange Gallic customs.

Well, she manages by locking herself in a strange Frenchman's bedroom who also happens to be dead. Oh my goodness, what will happen to her reputation if she can't escape in time. For her place in life, it's a fate worse than death.

I expect the comedy of manners and gentle humor is better aimed at English audiences than American. By and large, the series attempt at humor was much less successful than its trademark suspense. And, despite Natwick's droll performance, this is one of them.
23 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
POOR MISS BRACEGIRDLE!
tcchelsey8 April 2024
A couple of things to note. With a title character with this name, you know Hitchcock had to have a hand in it. He had a great sense of humor, albeit for dark comedy.

Series writer Marian Cockrell wrote this episode, and it's obvious she and Hitch had a couple of chuckles.

Second. Who better than to play upper-class, sheltered all her life Millicent Bracegirdle than Mildred Natwick, a master of character roles for years. Perhaps, the most recognized of actresses in supporting roles. Here's the interesting catch; she accidentally enters the wrong hotel room one night --gets locked in -- only to discover the gentleman guest is dead as a doornail. Now what?

Excellent writing, though Mildred Natwick steals the show and is just fun to watch, always the classy lady. A bit different episode for Hitchcock, actually a one woman show. Natwick worked with Hitch in THE TROUBLE WITH HARRY, and was nomiated for an Oscar in BAREFOOT IN THE PARK (1967).

Note the same quirky music that was used in early episodes of LEAVE IT TO BEAVER, and perfect for our heroine's prediacment.

From SEASON 3 remastered dvd box set. 2007 release. Universal.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Just a Lark
Hitchcoc27 June 2013
This is the G rated version of the episode where Joseph Cotten kills his girlfriend and then gets caught in a locked room. In this one a prissy old lady, traveling in France, inadvertently goes into the wrong room of a "sleeping" Frenchman and in trying to get out, breaks the doorknob. From then on, it's a battle against her own moral sense and practicality. She is afraid of the scandal that will ensue if anyone finds out she is in the room late at night. She tries waiting in the closet, under the bed, hoping to escape when the man gets up. Unfortunately, morning is a ways off and this exacerbates the situation. There is a monkey wrench in the works and things get even more complicated. All in all, a lightweight episode. Mildred Natwick does well as the spinster, caught in the trap of her own making.
21 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A very lighthearted episode. Not much to recommend.
b_kite1 April 2022
In 1907, Millicent Bracegirdle (Mildred Natwick) is taking a trip to France, as an upper-class British woman she is rather worried about the different customs and meeting and being around strangers, as she's lived a sheltered life around friends and family. When she finally makes it to France she sets up in a nice hotel and everything seems fine until one night she winds up accidently going into the wrong room of a sleeping Frenchman, now with the door handle falling off and no way out what is she to do. There's honestly not much here to recommend, the whole thing is very lighthearted and mostly played for laughs as you spend most of the episode with Natwick (who is good here by the way) running around trying to get out of the situation she's in. As with most of these there's a twist, but it too is played very lighthearted and mostly for laughs. Also of note Tita Purdom the horrible overacting actress from the season two opener "Wet Saturday" returns here in a small role and surprisingly does decently better.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Bland duty
TheLittleSongbird17 November 2022
Actually thought that "Miss Bracegirdle Does Her Duty" had some potential. Mildred Natwick was a fine actress and rarely disappointed, and had no doubt that she would do well here as the role sounded as though it would suit her. Robert Stevens was responsible for some fine episodes, Season 3 having coincidentally two of his best ("The Motive" and "The Glass Eye"). Have always liked droll humour, it more often than not worked in Hitchcock's bookending throughout this series, and there are episodes that are more reliant on humour than suspense that have worked well.

"Miss Bracegirdle Does Her Duty" is one of those episodes that could have executed this a lot better than it did. Had absolutely no problem with the lead performance, but it is a case (like quite a number of 'Alfred Hitchcock Presents' episodes) of the lead performance being better than the episode itself. It is not one of Stevens' worst episodes, nowhere near, or one of the worst of Season 3 (it never for example reaches "Sylvia" bad). It is also not one of the best. Not a terrible episode, but it did feel somewhat bland and a disappointment after "The Motive".

The best thing about "Miss Bracegirdle Does Her Duty" is Natwick, who is excellent and was clearly at ease with this type of humour. The acting is fine in general. Hitchcock's bookending is typically dry humoured and does amuse, more so than the humour in the rest of the episode.

Production values are suitably slick, simple but not cheap. The theme music is as macabre as ever.

However, "Miss Bracegirdle Does Her Duty" could have been a good deal better. Story-wise, it is pretty thin on the ground and emphasis on dialogue over anything eventful happening made it feel dull and over-stretched. Especially when the dialogue is very talky, too much so and some of it felt like it was there to pad out the episode. There is not much to it in terms of atmosphere, the droll humour came over more as tired and not particularly funny (other than in the bookending) and there is very little suspense.

Did also find the episode rather forgettable, not much here is innovative and little new is done with it. The ending is another going out on a whimper ones and another one of those where it was difficult to remember any of it. Stevens directs competently, but nothing feels inspired.

In conclusion, watchable but rather bland. 5/10.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed