James Neilson directed twelve episodes of 'Alfred Hitchcock Presents', some good ("Mail Order Prophet" and "Reward to Finder" in fact excellent), some not so good ("The Percentage" getting my vote as his weakest). Though none terrible certainly. "The Safe Place" is the final one of the twelve and did sound interesting. 'Alfred Hitchcock Presents' did character studies on the most part very well and Robert H Harris was a series favourite for very good reason.
"The Safe Place" is a very good episode. It is also a very good last one for Neilson, and while not quite "Mail Order Prophet" or "Reward to Finder" level it is one of his better outings. Some may prefer the more darkly suspenseful and creepier tales, including myself admittedly, but as said the series did a lot of good character studies and "The Safe Place" is not an exception. As far as Season 3 goes, it is not quite one of the best but it's quite high up in the high middle category.
So much is good. The acting is very good, with Harris proving once again why his reputation of being a series favourite was justified, doing sly and oddly charming very well. His character is an interesting one, one of those ones where you don't in any way approve of what is done but find that he is not hard to root for as well. Wendall Holmes is wonderfully overbearing too and Joanna Linville does vulnerable beautifully. Neilson directs in a controlled and taut manner, as well as fully allowing the cast to have fun. Hitchcock's bookending is as droll as ever and fits perfectly.
It's a nicely filmed episode and despite the location being simple it is not too basic. The series' main theme is wholly deserving of its iconic immediately recognisable status. It is also tautly and thoughtfully scripted while not taking itself too seriously, while the story always intrigues. Not as dark or as suspenseful as other entries in the series, but it never felt dull. Really liked the twist, it is true that it does come out of nowhere but it is also a complete surprise and cleverly staged.
Did feel however that some of the character decisions were unrealistically rash at times.
Also that Jerry Paris is somewhat miscast as the brother, too much of an implausible mismatch physically. Buyable as a best friend maybe, but not a brother.
Overall though, very good and nearly great. 8/10.
10 out of 10 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink