"Cheyenne" Gold, Glory and Custer - Requiem (TV Episode 1960) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Custer, Flynn and Greene
schappe16 February 2023
No, that's not a law firm, although it would have made an interesting one. They are united by this two-parter of Cheyenne, the 1941 movie "They Died With Their Boots On" and the 1876 battle both were based on, the Little Bighorn.

They Died With Their Boots On was the #1 movie of my youth. A local channel had a package of movies from Warner Brothers and this, at least to the kids on my street, was the gem of the collection. We'd watch it on our porch while my Mom served Lemonade and when it was over, go out into the back yard, refight the battle, arguing about who would get to be Custer this time.

Custer has been a lightning rod for criticism though our history. When we need a villain, he will absorb all of our blame. When we need a hero, he can be reinflated to one. In 1941 we needed heroes so the cinema's greatest hero at the time, Errol Flynn, played him. He was depicted as a flamboyant, self-involved and ambitious soldier but also a man of integrity who gets drawn into a conflict with Native Americans, whom he respects. The villains are the speculators and politicians who created the Gold Rush into the Black Hills.

Here he is played by the far less charismatic Lee Atwater as a realist looking for a military victory. Members of his command have contempt for the Native Americans, but he never voices any prejudicial view. Those conniving politicians are still the bad guys.

On You-Tube is an interview with Marlon Brando on the Dick Cavett Show in which he said that "Hollywood's view of Native Americans is that the only good Indian is a dead Indian. I grew up watching movie and TV westerns and I've never heard a hero or anyone else we are supposed to admire express such a view. Here Cheyenne actually dons the clothes of the tribe who raised him and views the battle in full Indian regalia, (but as a prisoner of the Sioux, who do not trust him). He went there to try to prevent the conflict.

The episode uses clips from TDWTBO and is thus a prisoner of the errors there, which shows the battle taking place in an arid plain and Custer lured into the battle by a small group of mounted warriors. It's a great battle scene but there's no river and no Indian village in sight. Also no Reno or Benteen.

Some reviewers have complained about Lorne Greene's performance as the prosecuting office in the trial of Reno. He's essentially playing the same character he played in 1957's Peyton Place, (the movie), and in the same swarmy way. He's a prosecutor with an ulterior motive. In Peyton Place, he's looking to run for Governor. Here he's in with the corrupt politicians who started the whole mess and making a scapegoat of Reno and a martyr of Custer to further their ambitions to take over the Black Hills. In both cases the part was written, and he would have bene directed to play it that way. Interestingly, this episode aired January 11, 1960. Bonanza premiered 9/12/59. Cheyenne was part of a wheel with Sugarfoot and Bronco so it's episodes could have been filmed far in advance of the broadcast dates. This may have been the very last thing Greene did before he became Ben Cartwright.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Yes, there was a seven foot Minniconjou Sioux by the name of Touch the Clouds .
wamblipasu17 August 2021
The idea that there wasn't a 6'6" Native is incorrect . The Miniconjous chief Lone Horn had a son named Touch the Clouds that was a 7 footer ! That being said there were the usual TV Hollywood historicaly inconsistent issues but that item is true.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
It's just a tv show..
dsrtblly21 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
...not many of them are accurate in every detail, but Lorne Green is probably the equivalent of a modern day liberal idiot
3 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"An innocent man will be destroyed, when the truth could save him!"
faunafan23 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Ironic that Irene Travers would make that plea to Cheyenne Bodie on behalf of Major Marcus Reno, when the man most wronged by the series of personal events in this story was standing before her. Reno is facing dereliction of duty charges after the 7th Cavalry's debacle at the Little Big Horn. On that day, Reno made a command decision to dig in with his 120 men, 40 of whom were wounded, rather than put them all at risk against what he claimed were thousands of Indians waiting to attack.

Days before Custer's last stand, Indian Commissioner Clay Brady has a plan to save the Sioux. He asks Cheyenne to try to convince a delegation of Indian chiefs from hostile tribes meeting with Sitting Bull to join others at Standing Rock Reservation, a place of safety from the "soldier coats." Knowing that the council will never listen to a white man other than "Father" Brady himself, Cheyenne is to go disguised as a chief of the southern Cheyenne tribes, who are already on the reservation. This means that he will be listed by the Army as a deserter, but Brady assures him that he will make sure the commandant knows of his mission. Unbeknownst to Cheyenne, Brady dies before such assurance can be given. In the meantime, Cheyenne attends the council and pleads the case as Brady had instructed, but to no avail. He does learn from the lovely and flirtatious young Indian girl Singing Waters (Andra Martin) that one of the Army's native scouts had betrayed Custer, but it's too late. Arrested by the opposing chiefs, he's taken to a hilltop from which he helplessly witnesses the Little Big Horn massacre. Then he's released to return to the Reservation to relate the defeat of "Squaw killer" Custer. Instead, he bursts into the trial of Marcus Reno, demanding to be heard. It wasn't because of Irene's self-serving and unreasonable plea that he sacrifice himself to save an innocent man. Cheyenne Bodie's dedication to justice is uncompromising, even if it's in behalf of a man whose character he loathes.

Lorne Greene's prosecutor is as bombastic as any lawyer ever on film, his overbearing disdain for Bodie's testimony obvious from the get-go and rather annoying. However, based on prior evidence only he has, the head of the Army's tribunal, Lt. Gen. Phillip Sheridan (Larry Dobkin), believes Cheyenne's entire narrative and declares the charges against Reno dismissed. Irene Travers turns up one more time, Reno close by her side, to thank Cheyenne. One can only imagine the regret she felt as she watched him ride away to find the 7th Cavalry's treacherous scout, knowing that Cheyenne Bodie is the most honorable man she'd ever met--as Sheridan had said, interested only in truth and justice at the risk of his own life. Of course, if by then she couldn't see the stark contrast between Cheyenne and Maj. Reno, she was likely never to admit or learn from her mistake.

One last observation. Cheyenne Bodie's impersonation of a southern Cheyenne chief, appropriately named "Touch the Sky," was true to accounts of the towering stature of some Native warriors from Old West history. It's doubtful that any of those men were quite as imposing as he was, though, height notwithstanding. Clint Walker stood alone in the pantheon of Western heroes, so it was completely understandable when he appeared in full regalia that Singing Waters would be immediately taken with him, even letting him know that her father's price was only 30 ponies for her. She would later become Wahleeah and win him over in "Yellowstone Kelly," no bride price required.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
just too many flaws
sandcrab27723 March 2018
To believe the story it is necessary to accept that a 6 foot 6 inch tall indian could fool any other indian...of course it couldn't so the whole story is a fiasco that shouldn't have become a part of the cheyenne series...having the pompous lorne green in the cast didn't help matters...native americans must get a chuckle out of watching white men portray them to no avail...
4 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed