"Kavanagh QC" Nothing But the Truth (TV Episode 1995) Poster

(TV Series)

(1995)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The Crown vs. Young Master Ewan McGregor
AZINDN3 May 2006
"Nothing But the Truth" features a very young and long haired, Ewan McGregor in a role that leaves everyone guessing to the very end. Did he or didn't he? Who's telling the truth? Who is the real victim? One of the series from Kavanagh QC (Queen's Counsel), the superior storyline evidence the high caliber of British drama that Americans rarely find on regular mundane weekly television except PBS Masterpiece Theater. In the title role is the late versatile character actor, John Thaw as James Kavanagh a champion for equal justice in and out of the court. He is harried with an enormous case load, and faces the shaky possibility of loosing his unhappy marriage, as well as his spoiled yuppie puppy offspring at home. Adding to his problems is the case of the Crown versus David Armstrong (Ewan McGregor).

McGregor's character is a young Cambridge student accused of raping an older woman who is the client of a construction company where David works as a summer laborer. The son of an industrial captain, David has wealth, and the good reputation of a gentleman. He is candid and forthright making him a perfect client. Kavanagh is confident and assured of David's innocence. The alleged rape victim (Alison Steadman) is a forty-something housewife. She has an unfaithful husband and her failing marriage leaves her lonely and vulnerable. Not so old that she is unattractive, Kavanagh argues she is not the kind of woman a rich and hot Cambridge boy would have an interest. He asserts the accuser enticed David into her home for a little 'afternoon delight'.

At the crux of the episode is the prejudice that rape is the fault of the victim. Who do we believe -- adorable and respectable David, or a troubled housewife with an itch for firm young flesh? As lawyers spar and examine the incident, the prejudices that surround issues of older women/younger man, class, status, and rape in today's society becomes all the more raw, exposed, and incendiary.
18 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A solid start to a great legal drama
TheLittleSongbird16 April 2010
I will begin by saying I am very fond of Kavanagh QC, mainly because I have a fondness for its star John Thaw. Nothing But The Truth is a solid start to a great, underrated legal drama, with a compelling story, a good script and excellent performances. Starting with the story, we are left asking ourselves, who do we believe, a young rich student or a housewife? Did he rape her or not? And how it unfolds at the end is fairly unpredictable to say the least. The script is also good, as is the direction, particularly in the courtroom scenes. And it was nice to see Kavanagh's family, and a lovely Lisa Harrow as Kavanagh's wife. The acting is typically excellent, with John Thaw brilliant as Kavanagh, the lovely Geraldine James as Eleanor Harker and Ewan McGregor appealing in an early role as the student David Armstrong. The episode does start off rather slowly, but overall it is a solid start for a great legal drama. 9/10 Bethany Cox
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Where's his name?
ykborna2 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Here is a good courtroom drama, with Ewan McGregor in an early role. It's the story of a woman who accuses of rape the man who's digging her pool. While both sides had plausible arguments, I'm surprised that the prosecuting attorney didn't point out that a guy sho's been sweating in the hot sun all morning would be dusty and smelly and sweaty, and probably not very attractive to seduce unless he's been made to shower first. . This looks to be the pilot for the Kavanagh series. It is not included in the lineup of available Prime episodes, unless you want to add an additional subscription to the hefty Prime membership. But if it is the first program, and John Thaw is in almost every scene in the episode, dominating them all, WHY is his name not included in the credits?
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Superb legal drama from the UK
safenoe7 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I first watched this Kavanagh intro, Nothing But The Truth, and pretty much the rest of seasons one, two and three back in the 1990s when Kavanagh QC debuted. What a fine British/English legal drama series. Thankfully I've been able to catch up with most of the rest of the series on social media platforms only recently, being more than a quarter-of-a-century or so later!

Ewan McGregor, yes the Ewan McGregor plays the accused in Nothing But The Truth. Alison Steadman, famous for her forest scene with Patrick Malahide in The Singing Detective, plays the accuser. The denouement was a masterstroke in writing because when we see the first two jurors cast a guilty verdict, then the next one a not guilty, meaning that the remaining nine voted not guilty, meaning 10 out of 12 voted not guilty. This is significant because the judge ruled that he was prepared accept a verdict of which 10 agreed to avoid a hung jury.

The ending was a bitter blow to Kavanagh because he wonders if he got the accused off and free to wonder society.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Nothing But the Truth
Prismark103 February 2020
I am so used to seeing John Thaw playing coppers. It was slightly odd to see him as a barrister with his hair slicked back.

James Kavanagh is a northerner working in chambers down in London where his colleagues take a dim view of life up north.

His home life is a bit of a wreck, it seems his wife had an affair with a younger man.

In the first story Kavanagh is defending an undergraduate student David Robert Armstrong (Ewan McGregor) who also works as a part time gardener who has been arrested of raping a middle aged housewife.

This is a world away from Rumpole of the Bailey. A very slick first episode, there is even an expensive boat scene as Kavanagh goes sailing with his family.

The producers struck it lucky with the casting of rising star McGregor. I am not convinced that Thaw convinced me that he was a tough, rugged barrister. Even his daughter seems to be unsure about his job. She asked him what I thought were rather stupid questions after his cross examination.

The let down were the trial scenes. I understand the need for dramatic effect over any basis in reality but here it was pedestrian and cliched.

There was a scene where Armstrong is being badgered in cross examination and Kavanagh never objects. After the victim is cross examined by Kavanagh I thought there was no need for the Defence to bring in the accused to give evidence.

At least the episode does acknowledge the difficulties that victims of rape face. However the cynical ending has been done lots of time so even that was not original.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed