(TV Series)

(1992)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
I thought this was a great episode all the way around.
reb-warrior8 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I thought this was a great episode all the way around. Love that they had Charlie Matlock again, played by Andy Griffith. Love the old flashbacks and history, and how something that happened back then comes full circle. Also, it's kind of epic that the son whose father is in jail for murder for life, is now accused of killing the son of the man his father murdered.

I think for me the part that raised my eyebrows, was the truth about Sylvia Martell. Brian Martell's mother. The murder in my eyes was premeditated. The woman, enraged after seeing her lover, Jake Kendell, with another woman left and went and got Charlie Matlock's wrench at his garage and then went back to see Jake pretending she forgave and wanted to be with him, but then she killed him with the wrench, then threw the wrench out the window to be found. She planned the murder. She tried to frame Charlie Matlock. She let her husband go to jail for 40 years for it. To top it off she didn't even raise her son and he was left with an aunt and uncle to raise. How is this woman who was cheating on her husband with Jake, a nice, gentle lady? And why does she get a pass? Because she's an old lady now and has allegedly lived with the guilt all these years? Anyway, no outrage, just kind "oh well" from everyone.

There are lots of twists and turns in this one making it complex and interesting. 9/10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Strange ending
Christopher37023 May 2024
I enjoyed this episode right until the last couple of minutes outside the courthouse. The sister of one of the guilty parties exits the courthouse and slaps Conrad so hard that he nearly falls over on the steps and then says she broke his tooth.

Ben and his daughter laugh at what just happened! I found it incredible how this blatant incident of assault occurring right in front of their eyes is just casually laughed off by the two lawyers while the assaulter just walks away. What the hell?!

She should have been immediately reprrehanded and charged with assault for what she did.

I was really shocked how Ben and his daughter found such a serious incident like that to be funny when it was anything but, especially if Conrad really has his tooth cracked or broken by the slap.

The rest of the episode was great and had me guessing who the killer was right up until the end, but that slap scene really should have been reworked to where that woman was held and charged for assault. Hitting someone like that, especially outside a courthouse should be a charged offense.... especially with two lawyers as witnesses.

Ben just laughing at the incident was strangely out of character for him to do...but I think it was in character for his daughter who I just can't warm up to because she comes off a bit too smug to me when she's doing her job and interviewing suspects. I can see her taking delight and laughing at Conrad's slap, but not Ben. A serious lawyer like him witnessing an assault on his employee and good friend should have generated a much different reaction than humor from him.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed