"Naked City" Meridian (TV Episode 1958) Poster

(TV Series)

(1958)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Excellent Series
gordonl5616 April 2014
Warning: Spoilers
NAKED CITY – Meridian – 1958

This is the first episode of the 1958 to 1963 Police series, THE NAKED CITY. The series covered stories of New York's 65th Precinct. The leads were played by John McIntire, James Franciscus, Harry Bellevar, Paul Burke and Horace McMahon. The first 39 episodes of the 138 episode run were half hour productions. The remaining episodes were expanded to an hour running time.

Two dirt poor slum kids, Pat DeSimone and Joseph Walsh decide it is time to move up in the world. They get hold of a gun and plan to pull a stick up. The pair hit a small out of the way jeweller just as it closes for lunch. They knock the old guy down and start rifling the take into a sack.

Their first job and things immediately start to go wrong. A passing beat cop looks in and sees the robbery in progress. He pulls his weapon but Walsh fires first and the cop goes down. The two gunmen hightail it down the street but run into another cop coming their way. Off in the other direction they flee.

Every which way they go there seems to be Police. The two duck into a sporting goods store and are quickly cornered. The two grab a pair of hostages and arm themselves with a couple of shotguns on display. The detectives are summoned to try and get everyone out alive. Detectives, John McIntire and James Franciscus get the call. McIntire uses the bullhorn to ask the boys to surrender. He gets a couple of blasts from a shotgun in response.

DeSimone decides that perhaps the life of crime is not what he wants. He is all for letting the hostages go and surrendering. Walsh however intends to go out in a blaze of gunfire and damn the hostages. The Police use the novel method of using the store fire sprinklers to "flush" the boys out.

A pretty good first episode of a gritty, shot on location, series. The episode was written by one time Oscar winner, Stirling Silliphant. His Oscar was for, IN THE HEAT OF THE NIGHT.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Take whatever you want but please don't kill us!
sol-kay26 August 2013
****SPOILERS*** In it's TV debut the highly successful crime series begins much like the movie "The Naked City" that its based on. We have an aerial view of Manhattan Island and the people who both work and live in it. As the camera pans down to the streets we see 15 year old Arturo, Pat DeSimone, mug this old man by bashing his head in and taking off with a gun the man, who's a watch and jewelry repairman, had in his lunch pale. Arturo then teams up with his fellow greaser Lefty, Joseph Walsh, who are both planning to make a big score by knocking off a local jewelry store. The two brainless grease balls, who have enough grease & oil in their hair to fill up the tank of an SUV, then try to pull off a Jewel robbery on crowded West 58th Street in broad daylight with the streets filled with more cops then pedestrians. The two not that on the ball would be robbers end up slugging the what looked like 90 years old store owner and to make matters even worse shoot a cop who just happened to show up at the crime scene.

Going from dumb to dumber the two then takes off with about two dozen policemen on their tail to a gun show at Columbus Circle where their trapped like rats and are, another bright idea on their part, now planning to go out in a blaze of glory. That in order for them to finish off what had turned out to be definitely not their day. It's there where our hero's Lt. Don "Birdman" Muldoon, John MacIntire, and his young whipper snapper partner the just made NYPD Detective James Halloran, James Franciscus, are introduced to the TV audience as they show up at the scene in order to prevent things from getting even more worse and out of hand then they already are.

***SPOILERS***Stopping short from using fire power to catch the two fugitives from the law Det. Holloran has the store sprinkler system turned on to flush the two trapped and cornered rats out. For his part Auturo in seeing the writing on the wall let one of the two hostages go but in his partner Lefty wanting to duke or shoot it out with the police he soon ended up getting completely drenched. Lefty ended up with his full head of glorious hair or proud pompadour, that the girls were crazy about, so badly mussed up and water logged that to him it was far far worse then any punishment, including life behind bars or the death penalty, that the NY court system could have meted out on him.
8 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A bit overdone,but extremely funny!
ronnybee21129 April 2021
This is a great first episode of a great show. It may be overdone in spots but that only adds to the mostly-unintended humor of the whole show. Some of the message(s) are delivered with the subtlety of a sledgehammer on an egg,but this too only adds to the character and amusement value. To be clear,obviously nothing is 'funny' about the topics of any of the episodes,but the way many things are presented,and the over-the-top acting definitely make the show pretty dog-gone funny in my book. Plus,as a bonus,we get a fascinating look at 1958-1963 NYC and wow it was glorious!
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
First so of NC starts stale but gets good fast
belanger7520 February 2020
Warning: Spoilers
For some reason the around opening shot of the boy slugging a guard and obtaining a gun is not that a well-done. But first season series regular Franciscis has a fun domestic bit where his wife and daughter surprise with a gift of apparel. The ep gets very good before it ends. But the pretty girl should have stayed a hostage and lived. The series opener!
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Quality launch
lor_24 October 2023
The classic TV series gets an auspicious sendoff in this simple yet distinctive opener. It's designed to set the scene for the central characters as well as providing an exciting standoff against the criminals.

I've recently been watching the complete series of both "Combat!" and "Route 66", and was surprised to see that "Naked City" was so influential. A young criminal is Puerto Rican and we're introduced to him and his family, speaking Spanish that is untranslated -just as "Combat!" years later featured German and French dialogue regularly, and without subtitles. First episode was written by Stirling Silliphant, creator of "Route 66:, and the filming on location in New York City preceded the later series groundbreaking travels all over America instead of shooting on the studio backlot, both series produced by Herbert Leonard.

Leonard also narrates, colorful in showing NYC. Setting is Columbus Circle, with a robbery of a small shop on West 58th St., and then a shootout in the NY Coliseum (then new, but since torn down and replaced with the Time-Warner Center a/k/a Deutsche Bank Center).

The location photography is excellent and Irish captain John McIntire and boyish newbie plainclothes detective James Franciscus are empathetic heroes, latter with a typically wholesome '50s family.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed