"Quincy M.E." Stolen Tears (TV Episode 1982) Poster

(TV Series)

(1982)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"If someones life is erased it's called murder, what is it called if someones death is erased, that's a crime too you know." Classic Quincy.
poolandrews19 June 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Stolen Tears starts as Jew & Holocaust survivor Issac Koviac (Tha Wyenn) is run down & killed in what seems like an open & shut case of hit-and-run, however before he was killed Issac managed to get a written note to his friend & fellow Holocaust survivor Hyam Sigerski (Martin Baslam) saying that he saw one of the sadistic German prison guards from the Auschwitz concentration camp where they were held during World War II somewhere in Los Angeles. Hyam believes Issac was killed deliberately by this German guard to silence him & prevent his exposure, Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) & the LAPD aren't interested so in desperation Hyam talks to Quincy (Jack Klugman) who performed Issac's autopsy to try & convince him it was murder. Meanwhile an organisation lead by Cornelius Sumner (Norman Lloyd) is on a campaign to discredit people like Hyam & spread the filthy propaganda that the Holocaust never happen & it was all lies, doctored video footage & photo's plus false confessions...

Episode 18 from season 7 this Quincy story was directed by Georg Fenady & is one of those Quincy episodes where he has to use his medical expertise & detective skills to solve a crime as well as use his stiff moral backbone to confront & tackle a serious issue & I guess they don't come much more political, serious or sombre then the systematic extermination of over 6 million Jews in German concentration camps during the second World War but this is Quincy & he doesn't shy away from anything even an issue as heartfelt & emotional as this. To be honest this is quite a heavy issue & a surprising subject matter for the show to deal with but the one thing I really like about Quincy is the diversity of subjects & issues it can & does tackle, of course I think the show is at it's best when it mixes a solid social issue around an intriguing & entertaining murder mystery which Stolen Tears does quite effectively. I couldn't help thinking that maybe the issue of German concentration camps might be a little heavy for Quincy & at only 50 odd minutes in length it doesn't quite have the time to address some of the issue it raises but as a big fan of the show I still liked this episode all the same & it's as simple & straight forward as that.

As usual the show is competently made if a little cheap looking, I doubt the makers had much of a budget or a lot of time. This particular episode also gives the viewer a rare chance to see the inside of Danny's restaurants public toilets which I think has never happened before or since! The acting here is OK, Klugman as Quincy is just class & I could watch him all day while the guest stars do OK but aren't anything special.

Stolen Tears is a pretty sombre Quincy which deals with a difficult & still quite sensitive subject, I can't say it does it complete justice but it tries & there's time for a neat little murder mystery in between all the politics as well.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A murder mystery and a Holocaust debate
rayoflite2422 December 2015
Stolen Tears begins with an elderly man seeing someone that he recognizes outside an apartment building and following him until the pursued jumps into a car and runs him down in an alley. Quincy (Jack Klugman) conducts the autopsy and Lieutenant Monahan (Garry Walberg) tracks down who he believes is the driver of the car only to find him also dead of what appears to be a suicide. The police are ready to close the investigation when another man, Hyam Sigerski (Martin Balsam), comes forward alleging that both men died at the hands of a Nazi war criminal in hiding. Hyam also seeks help from Quincy in a public battle against the controversial leader of an organization, Cornelius Sumner (Norman Lloyd), that denies the Holocaust ever occurred.

I found this to be an OK episode where I enjoyed the beginning and the conclusion but found several parts in between to be pretty dull and far-fetched. On the positive side, we do have a murder mystery featured which I appreciated and found to be entertaining, but the parts where they were debating whether or not the Holocaust happened and trying to prove it in court were bordering on the preposterous. Would it really be up to the Los Angeles coroner to prove in a court of law that this well-documented event that occurred in another country actually happened? I also couldn't believe that the Cornelius Sumner character was being portrayed as having any type of credibility in the eyes of the public and media with his outrageous claims. Maybe his rhetoric would appeal to a cult following of conspiracy theorists who would listen, but the vast majority would dismiss everything he was saying outright.

Overall this is a rather average and unremarkable Season 7 episode that does feature a crime investigation but also tries to address a huge historical atrocity and does a rather clumsy job of it. It's a shame because we still see news stories where Nazi war criminals in hiding are outed to this day and the problem remains relevant, but it is just not told here in a competent manner.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Quincy strays even further from its original purpose.
planktonrules29 May 2013
After having re-watched all the "Quincy" episodes recently, I have learned that the very best episodes were the early ones. This is because they all were about solving crimes and seeing Quincy using forensics to do this was pretty exciting. However, after a while, fewer and fewer episodes were about crimes and more and more of the time they were about social causes and featured Quincy preaching at the audience about the issue of the week. "Stolen Tears" is one of the best examples of just how far the show had wandered from its original purpose. It comes off as exceptionally preachy and bad--even though the topic (Nazis and Holocaust deniers) are topics I usually might enjoy learned about...but NOT on "Quincy".

Quincy gets to do a bit of forensics when a Nazi war criminal does some killing in 1982. However, this only makes up a tiny portion of the show. Most is an utterly ridiculous story about a Holocaust denier--a guy who writes books and goes on the radio in order to promote his inane ideas. Now why Quincy would get involved in this really makes no sense and the show manages to annoy the audience. This is because in the SANE world, no reasonable person would deny the Holocaust and the show gives such stupid ideas the time of day. Plus, the idea of having Quincy PROVE the Holocaust occurred is pretty offensive and grandiose! It is a fact...no need for Quincy and the gang to spend 50 minutes trying to probe and prove it to the audience. Overall, an embarrassingly bad episode made tolerable only by a nice guest performance by Martin Balsam. Otherwise, a lot of rubbish. There is so much better about this sort of thing than this!
10 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed