"Perry Mason" Chapter One (TV Episode 2020) Poster

(TV Series)

(2020)

User Reviews

Review this title
27 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Perry Mason as Loser
alonzoiii-123 June 2020
All superheros must have an origin story. Perry Mason -- who never lost a case and never had a guilty client -- is the courtroom equivalent of Superman. Since Perry did not come to earth when the planet Krypton exploded and he was not bitten by a radioactive spider as a teenager, his story is going to be a little different.

Erle Stanley Gardner, the writer of the original Mason books, never came up with a backstory for Perry. From the first novel, his clients were innocent, his tactics edgy, his victories complete and total. While that leaves a clear pathway for an intrepid filmmaker to come up with any past he likes, any author has to figure out how to make Perry Perry.

In this opener, Mason is a low rent PI who sabotages himself by being greedy in an unsavory case. We see him in a courtroom sequence (where he testifies) in which it is clear he has a good sense of courtroom tactics. Mostly, though, we see him drink, conduct a sleazy investigation, fail to shave, and show his tattoo to his special friend while having painful sex. We are a long way from Raymond Burr.

Nonetheless, the atmosphere isn't out of line from the first few volumes of the Mason books. Gardner wrote for the leading private eye pulp of his day, The Black Mask -- the same place where Dashiell Hammett created Sam Spade -- and his books depict a police force and DA department where the rules are regularly ignored so that defendants can be railroaded. Sgt. Holcomb -- the awful policeman who appears in this episode -- was the lead police character in the Mason books of the 30s.

Mason in the books has a fierce sense of social justice. ESG himself created something called the Court of Last Resort, which was a small scale version of the Innocence Project If there is a key to Mason's character -- it is this sense that the system left to itself will railroad people, and it's his job to stop that from happening. Our character is not there yet. I am hoping we will see that happen as we move forward.
22 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Decent start
cruise0122 June 2020
(3.5 out of 5 stars).

Great cast. The plot about Perry taking on a case of a ransom child murder gone wrong. The story is dark for its material of kidnapping and ransom. I have never seen any other Perry Mason adaptations so i not sure how faithful or close this adaptation is. It is a slow direction. But intriguing story.
12 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Everything I expected, and more
jgibbdeuces8722 June 2020
What people should've realized before even watching this, was that Tim Van Patten (The Sopranos, Boardwalk Empire) was directing this series, and that it wasn't going to be your Grandpappy's Perry Mason. The trailer alone shows you that. As a fan of The Sopranos, and most definitely, Boardwalk Empire,(Arguably the best series ever) I found this pilot absolutely refreshing to the garbage that passes for TV these days. This is my first review since Joker, and I can see doing many more, but if I could binge this whole season, I don't think I would've been able to before watching this entire 1st season. Bravo to the directorial return of Tim Van Patten, and the premiere of Perry Mason! It's too bad that people couldn't enjoy a new original take on Perry Mason, but they sure can rave about a CW show, even if it's been running on fumes for a long time. People have no taste these days
31 out of 43 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Not your parent's Perry Mason
foreveramom25 June 2020
Very gritty.. Great acting. Just forget all about tv show with Raymond Burr.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
We're rooting for this guy?
adamkraemerla23 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
WARNING: SPOILERS, THOUGH NOT HUGE ONES

I'm writing my review of Episode 1 rather than the whole series because I have to assume it was greenlit after more than just the pilot. That said, what a miserable anti-hero they're trying to convince us to root for. What have we learned about him so far? 1) He can't fight. Or doesn't try. One of the two. 2) He's a terrible businessman. 3) When in possession of potentially lucrative photos, he either loses them or fails to make any money from them. 4) He was dismissed from the military. During the war. One assumes for conduct unbecoming. 5) The one thing he did discover, case-wise, we didn't actually see him find out. 6) When his ex-wife denies their son a toy because she's not willing to pay a cent (the 1931 equivalent to $0.17 today), he doesn't even try to point out that the kid is the one being punished. 7) When offered $6,000 for his failing dairy business (the 2020 equivalent of $101,000), he turns it down. From the woman who seems to like sleeping with him regardless of his indifference to her. And even though he's apparently so broke that he was one cent short of sending his son a Christmas gift. 8) When he seems to be connecting with the mother of the victim, he fails to find out literally ANYTHING from her. He asks her not a single question.

All in all, I can't count the ways (oh, yeah, eight) how much I dislike Mason. I was literally yelling at the screen at his seeming incompetence in his professional and personal lives. I'll give it another episode, but right now, I'm hurt that the show runners want me to root for this guy. I liked Thomas Covenant better.
14 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Amazing
faruktopak199822 June 2020
Slow start but matthew rhys perfect choice, music ,costume designer , production designer amazing . Looking forward other episodes
12 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
1x01
formotog22 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It was okay. I'm not familiar with any of the original Perry Mason works so I can't comment there. But this pilot was just standard as far as pilots go. Some pilots are very good at subtly introducing characters, plot points, settings etc. but I can't say this one was that good. Sometimes dialogue felt unnatural and a bit cliché and the episode as a whole was quite slow. That being said, it's a very dark crime and the episode has opened up for a lot of intrigue. I'm a fan of the whole 1930s look; the costume and set design are amazing. From a direction standpoint it was good, nothing spectacular. Generally the pilot did a good job of introducing Perry Mason and giving some insight into him. I just hope that as we go along, this show will give me reason to believe that it will be more than just another detective series

Low 7
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Superb characterisation and authenticity
tm-sheehan28 April 2023
My Review -Perry Mason.

Season 2. My Rating 9/10 Streaming both series on Foxtel HBO.

I really enjoy this new perspective on the characters created by Earle Stanley Gardner first published in 1933 .

The character of Perry Mason was inspired by Earl Rogers, a trial attorney who appeared in 77 murder trials but lost only three.

While the Perry Mason novels seldom delved deeply into characters' lives, the novels were rich in plot detail which was reality-based and drawn from his own experience This is where the new series writing team headed by Jack Amiel have excelled in both series in portraying Perry Mason as a flawed but clever attorney .

The two main characters Matthew Rhys as Perry Mason and Juliette Rylance are perfection and a stark contrast to Raymond Burr the original Perry and Barbara Hale as Della Street The writers on the new series have succeeded in highlighting their characters imperfections and vices like a painter who colours in their subject to give life to their subject.

The 1957 - 1966 series was in black and white and so were the characters as impressive as they were . Episodes always highlighted the crime and the trial and didn't delve into the lives very much of Perry and Della.

Both instalments of this new 2020 2023 8 episode are set in early 1930's Los Angeles unlike the original 1957 - 1966 hit television series of 271 episodes which were mostly separate cases still set in Los Angeles but with no particular era . It just looked contemporary to the era of the many 1950's 60's we we're watching at that time .

The entire technical team of Production Designers ,set decorators costume designers and Art Directors should be applauded for the authenticity of 1930's Depression era Los Angeles that they have recreated even the opening title credits look like a Film Noir 30's movie.

Composer Terence Blanchard's score also evokes the era and the vehicles including the automobiles and Perry's zippy motor cycle are of museum quality.

Series 2 plot line takes place in 1933 after the months following the Dodson trial of series one. An aimless Perry leans on Della to keep the law firm afloat.

Perry Mason takes on a case defending two unemployed Mexican immigrants Rafael and Mateo who are accused of shooting a prominent but dodgy land and investment developer.

As the case gets more and more complex Perry Mason's reputation and future are on the line because of his unorthodox practices.

One of the many things I enjoy about Welsh actor Matthew Rhys 's portrayal of Perry Mason is his vulnerability and disregard for conformity. Welsh actors like Matthew Rhy's Richard Burton and Peter O'Toole seem to be able to convincingly portray male characters with flaws who succeed in spite of their defects of character.

The script writers have even managed to convey the moral attitudes and discrimination towards homosexuality at that time which was of course was seen as an abomination demanding a prison sentence.

Della Street played by Juliet Rylance leaves no doubt that she is a lesbian having to live her life in the shadows of underground same sex Jazz clubs where illegal liquor is on tap and the bohemian inhabitants of LA gather.

Hamilton Berger District Attorney played by Justin Kirk is being blackmailed for his liaisons with various male lovers and this has implications for Perry Mason's case as well as threatening the reputation DA. Hamilton Berger.

I'll enjoy watching this series again in its entirety as weekly episodes are a little difficult to keep up with the the developments of the previous week.

I don't know if Earle Stanley Gardiner would have approved with this new version as his characters have obviously been tampered with .

However I think it's a great new look that displays originality giving the characters a fresh look as vulnerable and much more interesting human beings .

I really hope we see a third series of this quality production.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Steady-ish Start
GB6519 July 2020
Not being familiar with either the novels or the Raymond Burr version I wasn't really sure what to expect. I knew the previous TV incarnation was of a highly successful, polished attorney and I knew this was meant to be his earlier days. However, it just seems to me to be another lazy idea of using a former popular TV character and either revamping it or offering a different slant on it. Nothing in it grabbed me and really made me want to pursue it further but I will give it another couple of episodes to see if it picks up. I'm just not sure why it's Perry Mason; just create a new character.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Great
BeGerman24 June 2020
It's not the copy and past version of the old show. God so. I love the odea of a younger and unconventional PM. The good thing of the format are the tell us a story like a novel. So we have time over 8 episode to see the main characters are growing or chancing.

I like the 30 Hollywood styling of the show and the perfect product design.

What a wonderful cast. U can see the fun they have playing her own character and play together. It's the time if depression and the dark brain lighting lets smell the dust. It's not the time of clean tie lawyer, but start a carrier or the walk into an area with white clean shirts and suits. A good and interesting first chapter. Can't wait to see the next.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Underwhelming but not bad.
travinitrav22 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Doesnt feel like classic Perry Mason. I am fairly certain it started as a generic depression-era noir cop thriller and somebody got the license to the Perry Mason name then a bunch of changes were made late in development to make it all work. Its HBO, and they have to remind you its HBO by inserting sizable quantities of nudity, sex, swearing, racism, and dead children so there's no mistakes made on your part. Aside from the dead kid none of it really adds to the atmosphere. I guess that means its gratuitous but I don't judge. I'm fine with sex and nudity so long as it adds to the story, which it rarely does. I think 21st century producers keep forgetting there's tons of free porn all over the internet, so they can now safely skip time-wasting sex scenes and get back to the murders or whatever. There's also an overabundance of color grading making 1931 LA look surreal, and also annoyingly similar to most other contemporary movies and TV shows (video game inspired). Not much originality there. A series like this probably would have benefitted from more natural lighting/coloring because here its a little distracting. The characters come across as a little over the top. With the exception of our hero and his wealthy lawyer boss and the little boys mother, most seem like they're trying too hard to prove they're Olde Timey and it just feels weird. The story about a kidnapped boy is actually pretty enticing, but there's too much background fluff to really grab me and make it interesting. In 57 minutes the hero covers very little territory and I'm guessing they want to run this exactly like other modern shows with an A,B, and C story that slowly run parallel and culminate at the end of the season. The main characters dont get much development either, theres a lot of drawn out scenes which were probably intended to add atmosphere but really just feel plodding and pointless. This is a start difference from something like Deadwood, that also didnt move too fast but managed to get several stories begun, one finished, and a bunch of characters fleshed out to three dimensions, all within the pilot. Six Feet Under also accomplished a lot in just one episode, as well as Boardwalk Empire, and Game Of Thrones or so I was told. I'm not saying the new Perry Mason is bad, but I hope future episodes pick up the pace with either better developed stories or characters, and more accomplished each episode. For now its passable entertainment if you've run out of everything else, and thanks to quarantine, I have.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
George Smiley repalces James Bond in a Bond movie.
nilanshpandey23 June 2020
The Perry Mason I knew from the novels was a self assured, confident, charismatic, sharp minded guy, out witting anyone and everyone, a legal genius, pulling plans out of his hat, always almost crossing the line, but knows when to stop.

The Perry Mason that we get here is a almost a hollow shell of a man, barely managing his life. Tired, lonely, no direction in life, getting beaten up by mafia wannabe movie producers chums.

It's like somebody George Smiley has replaced James Bond in a bond movie.

The set up to 1930 is great, the sets are great, camera, cinematography, color, production everything is to the point, apart from the main guy.

Instead of being a thriller/suspenseful legal drama (Perry Mason is hell of a lawyer) they have made this into a hard boiled noir. It's more like a character from a James Hadley Chase novel then Perry Mason.
27 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good start
emadalbalawi30 June 2020
Looks like we have a new great series from HBO, And Matthew Acting is perfection
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This works
csteinmayer-251412 September 2020
The lead up to the Mason we all know and love. It's here, little glimmers, little hints. Everyone has to start somewhere. This is it. Brilliant. Love it.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not an appealing character
billsoccer3 August 2020
Wasn't expecting a drunk Perry Mason. Hope this leads somewhere
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Why is this called Perry Mason?
keithhaugen27 June 2020
This character has very little to do with Gardner's lawyer. This guy is just a stereotypical 1930s era private detective, so why use the Perry Mason characters?
24 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not Perry Mason
pauli_gomez22 June 2020
The show is not bad per se. It is a very, very dark and sad story in a 1932 setting. Very good acting, a Phillip Marlowe feeling, all well and good. But it is not Perry Mason. For instance, Perry Mason was a lawyer and he was in a much better economic and emotional situation that the lead character of this show. I am disappointed, as I was hoping for a good retelling of the classical story. I was ready for a darker, sadder stoy, but not for a complete change in Perry Mason's core.
28 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Using the name Perry Mason without the Spirit
cedarparkchump5 July 2020
I have watched the original Perry Mason TV show, one or two of the subsequent movies,and I have even seen one or two of the Perry Mason movies from the 1930's.

I agree with most other reviewers: HBO's new series is not Perry Mason. I think where a lot of us have trouble with this new version is that if I were on trial, I would want the Perry Mason played by Warren Williams or Raymond Burr representing me. Both were men of substance, who earned the respect of friend and adversary alike. In one episode of the show, Hamilton Berger even refers a friend in trouble to Perry for help. I can't see where the Peeping Tom with a camera I saw on episode one of this show is going to be that man any time soon.

If HBO wanted to do a graphic film-noir type show, there are any number of detectives from the old pulp novels they could have resurrected. Using the Perry Mason name to gin up an audience for this mediocrity is a real turn-off.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
This is NOT Perry Mason
kathytexan-1258522 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This is so dark and disgusting, I don't know where to begin. Matthew Rhys is a fine actor, but I didn't enjoy his role as a drunken, degenerate loser. The reason I love Raymond Burr's version of Perry Mason, is that it's about a classy, highly intelligent attorney who knew how to win cases. Since when do we have a younger Perry Mason who's a sloven? I doubt Earl Stanley Gardner ever envisioned Perry as a falling down drunk living in filthy farmyard squalor. The art direction was so effective, I could almost smell his B.O.

Why besmirch a highly successful series that is still watched by so many on MeTV and the Sundance Channel? If the creators had such a strong urge to create this slimy garbage, why not take a chance on a new series with a different name? Obviously, they hoped to capitalize on the Perry Mason brand.

I will NOT be watching the next seven episodes. The only reason I watched the first episode was that I hoped it might get better. Not a chance. Call it what you will, this is NOT Perry Mason.
27 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
If the plan is to stretch this opening crime....
rusoviet24 June 2020
......through the entire season - come on really? Lithgow is good and I'm no fan of his but he is - the rest are decent. Next episode had best have enough of something to chew on instead of watching the protagonist on a bender for the final 5 minutes. Good scripts, even for a season, know how to engage the viewer.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Bait and switch
jamarkon104 July 2020
This "Perry Mason" has nothing to do with the Erle Stanley Gardner books. Perry is a detective? Nobody likes being tricked. A different name or a series more related to the books would have changed 1 star to 5. Shame on the producers.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
not what i expected
MiketheWhistle22 June 2020
First off, having lost a child the story is extremely difficult for me to watch and that might influence my opinion of the overall show. I really didn't like this first ep very much but one ep doesn't make or break a series so I'm not making an opinion about the series at this point.

I've done some reading, and having Mason essentially do PI work fits with the early writings of Ear Stanley Garnder, but Mason is still supposed to be an attorney which nothing in the first ep says he is an attorney, so I don't understand why there is this change. This is an obvious change from all the other video adaptions and that's fine and can work but I hope they at least keep it the same as the wrtiings.

Regardless, the acting is very good, and I've always enjoyed Rhys very much as well as Lithgow and I only vaguely recognize a couple other actors but feel they all did a pretty good job.

To say the story is very dark is an understatement and will likely be quite a shock for most. One thing I will note is that gratuitous nudity isn't my thing, and this had some. Nudity doesn't bother me, and take for example Sharon Stone's interview scene was a powerful scene, but I don't think one scene in particular for Mason was really needed.

At this point I'd say it's dealer's choice regarding the series.
20 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Chapter 1
Prismark1023 June 2020
When Raymond Burr's Perry Mason returned in a series of star studded glossy television movies. They were enjoyable albeit cheesy.

This HBO adaptation has gone for a noirish origin story. Set in 1932, Matthew Rhys portrays Mason as a shady lowlife private investigator in LA. More Mike Hammer than ace attorney.

The first episode has frantic parents trying to retrieve their baby that has been kidnapped. The family are not even wealthy and the baby is found dead.

Perry Mason is bought into investigate the kidnapping by the wealthy elder of the church the parents attend. It might be that the parents could become suspects.

After Perry Mason got chased down by naked fat comic actor Chubby Carmichael. Who incidentally nearly caught him while Mason was getting away in a car. It rapidly went downhill. It was listless and I got bored.

Timothy Van Patten who directed many episodes of Boardwalk Empire has made this opener. The casting of Jefferson Mays reminded me of the down on his luck hard boiled detective drama, I am the Night from 2019.

This was unimaginative and future episodes really need to buck up.
16 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Disappointing this is not Perry Mason
sharonphoenix28 June 2020
Perry Mason is a criminal defence lawyer in the novels and short stories originally written. This isn't Perry Mason. The crime committed in this episode looks like it is going to get strung out across the series.

It's a no from me. I'd save yourself the time. Dreary. Dreadful. What a shame
6 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Pregnant ppl close your eyes for 3 mins
moriahlee-4371419 July 2020
I was so excited to watch what I anticipated was going to be HBOs next big show. BUT I was horrified at the opening scene with the baby. I am not sensitive to blood and guts however as a pregnant person and mom to a toddler the opening scene will most definitely give me nightmares tonight. I yelled to my husband SHUT IT OFF!
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed