Phantom Images (2011) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Fragmentary and Inconclusive
ekeby20 February 2017
The dialog is interesting, though the narration is flowery. There are some genuinely interesting interactions going on, though the pacing and organization of thoughts/scenes is so fragmented it never added up to anything for me.

This feels like a filmed play. There's an attempt to explain this--rehearsals for a movie that will never be filmed--but it feels like a cop out. It would have been more interesting to see these characters in context, not just sitting in two chairs at a table on a bare stage. Or endless variations thereof.

This film--as with actual filmed plays--is pretty talky. What action there is feels and looks like play acting, particularly because the sense of a largely empty stage is omnipresent. I'm not sure if I was supposed to be watching actors rehearsing a scene of if I was watching a materialization of the narrator/author's imagination. Or a combination of both.

Now this lack of clarity might be seen as a good thing. Or not. Depending upon your tolerance for ambiguity. What might be of interest to some are discussions of the rift between generations of gay men, and the difficulty for some black men to define their role in life.

I have mixed feelings about the movie. It's definitely ambitious, but it verges on the pretentious. I have no doubt that the author is trying to say something significant, but the message has been obscured by what is really just lazy movie-making. Show it. Don't just say it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
a big surprise
GayFilmViewer28 November 2011
Warning: Spoilers
THIS REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS.

When was the last time you watched a film twice in a row? I've only done it a handful of times. Sometimes it is because the movie was a joy, occasionally because it was thought provoking or, more rarely, because it is something so completely different from what was anticipated. "Phantom Images" is all of the above.

The narrative dispenses with the usual three-act formula of a Hollywood screenplay and provides the viewer with a 'dramatic essay' as the opening titles indicate. The thesis statement of this essay is that, in the quest for heterosexual normalcy we, as gay men, may have lost more than we have gained. The essay doesn't provide us with an easy answer – in fact, my fellow Thanksgiving Day viewers of the film came away with different conclusions about the ending. The discussion continued through dinner and lead to the second screening immediately after.

The essayistic structure reminded me of Jean-Luc Godard's "Two or Three Things I know About Her" when watching the film the second time. However, Godard's film benefits from greater length, more locations and a significantly broader scope.

This brings me to my biggest criticism of the movie – the single location of the story. Though the choice makes sense in terms of what the filmmakers were doing, I was left feeling a bit claustrophobic.

Still, the performances were very good and the direction thoughtful and restrained. This is truly a must for any gay man's DVD collection.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed