Torn: A Shock Youmentary (2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Engaging mockumentary with bite
gary-simpson217 May 2014
Low budget filmmaking is the backbone of the horror movie industry. Of course, there's low budget and really low budget... and then there's first time writer/director Justin Carter's TORN: a SHOCK YOUmentary, which cost a mere £1,500 to make. Not that you'd know if from the finished product. With its lush cinematography, large cast and lofty ambitions (most of which are realised), Carter's film is a triumph of aspiration over limitation.

TORN is a movie of two halves. The first half is slower and more restrained, and represents an intimate examination of family and friends in the grip of tragedy. More thriller than horror, and more documentary than either, it's a measured affair that allows us to get to know the characters and the unfortunate circumstances in which they find themselves. It's not without chills, especially during the nocturnal scenes, but is more concerned with psychology than scares. Carter and his cast do an admirable job of both eliciting our sympathies for the unfortunate protagonists and arousing our suspicions (something about them isn't right, we just can't quite put our finger on what...) He's also careful to ground the story in nature and humanity, subverting the potentially supernatural elements.

The second half is a self-conscious change of both pace and emphasis, and comes as something of a surprise. I won't spoil any of the twists and turns, but the sedate, almost dreamy atmosphere is replaced by a frantic tone and an action-packed narrative, placing horror firmly at the forefront. As with so many things, less is more in the horror genre, which Carter understands. Strategically-lit glimpses of his villain imply far more than any amount of explicit CGI trickery, and the practical prosthetics and makeup are excellent. Making a virtue of his budgetary restrictions, the director eschews elaborate sets for the scariest location of them all, the woods at night, which is the setting for some of the creepiest moments this side of BLAIR WITCH.

TORN isn't perfect. Some of the peripheral performances are less than stellar, and Carter's scripted dialogue sometimes jars with the form. Artifice is the enemy of found footage and mockumentaries, both of which work best with a looser, more freeform approach. Carter is more comfortable than most directors with silence, which he uses to memorable effect, and there are elements of improvisation, but scripted material is allowed to dominate. These are minor quibbles, however, and do little to detract from the impact of the film.

Low budget filmmakers have to be expert scavengers, and Carter proves he has a keen eye for found detail. He makes lavish use of the stunning Devonshire countryside, which, along with the aforementioned cinematography, affords the visuals an epic sweep, and evokes mood and immediacy through a variety of quirky close-ups and eccentric aesthetic details. The attention to characterisation is enhanced by a talented cast, and the score is first rate, helping to ramp up the tension. Smart, stylish and scary, TORN is low-budget genre filmmaking at its best.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
My Review Of "Torn: A Shock Youmentary"
ASouthernHorrorFan20 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
"Torn: A SHOCK YOUmentary" is a faux documentary from director Justin Carter that takes the lore of the British lore of werewolves in the countryside into the world of mockumentary/found footage storytelling. The film takes place in the Devon village of Orchardlea and stars Phil Baker, Charlotte Bird, Simon Burbage, Martin Challinor, Prudence Catley, Sam Burns, Danny D'Anzieri and Kit Cox. "Torn" tells the story of a group of friends fighting against the belief that they are responsible for the death of one of their ilk after a vicious attack in the countryside. A documentary crew is hired to film the events leading up to the capture and kill of the creature they say killed one of their own, proving the friends innocence.

"Torn: A SHOCK YOUmentary" doesn't really offer a new story or concept in this fake documentary but it does do one really cool thing, the film takes the creature horror of the werewolf back to the creepy countryside of jolly ol' England, far from the pavement and sophistication of the urban lycanthrope. Which automatically makes the story somehow seem more authentic. The beast roaming the English countryside leaving behind a wake of blood and death is timeless and classic. That is where this film centers at as a foundation. The actually character builds and story arc are less than clever, offering only a glimpse into this spooky rural world on edge as a killer runs about. Most of the film stays on the actually characters as they hunt for the beast, weaving in and out of melodrama and feign self-importance of dire situations. A lot of times in cinema when too much is implied then nothing is really implied at all. The focus on the groups situation as opposed to physical action and events to carry the moments wasn't enough to convince me of the nightmare elements of "Torn". Not like-say-"Blair Witch" or "Little Big Boy".

The acting and visual concepts are met by director Justin Carter, with a lot the story almost reaching full momentum into real horror potential, there was just too much down time with unnecessary melodrama from the characters to pull off a full fledge horror situation. Mostly "Torn" is a lot of talking and very little action. I was bored through most of the film until the final act. There is a lot of dialog and situations throughout this film that seem forced or contrived which takes away from the thing being scary. "Torn" is a low budget project with some pretty nice moments and some decent acting but there was a lack of suspense or thrilling nature to the over all atmosphere that should have been there to keep me connected to the screen.

The effects and soundtrack for "Torn are both hit and miss with some moments coming off nicely while others fall flat. I am not big on spoiling a film so I am not going to call out any particular moments so that I don't given anything away, lets just say that fake stuff shouldn't look so fake if your gonna let the camera stay on it longer than the eye can blink. The blood worked well and the last act was intense enough which is a nice end to the mockumentary set-up. As far as the sounds that play out in the film, I found them more off-putting than captivating. Some times the soundtrack just didn't go with the story's chilling intent or created a flat line effect when it was meant to chill. However with all the negative elements I experienced while watching "Torn", I have to say that it took the sub genre serious, had a creepy concept and managed to complete the story's arc. This one is a 50/50 for me as a horror fan, and as a fan of British horror.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed