As with all first seasons, you got to give it time. Damn you Netflix. This could have been a good start.
I can see the purists not liking this because there is quite a departure from the show. However, that isn't what didn't work for me. It was a lot darker than it needed to be and the hook wasn't as hopeful.
Firstly what worked, at least for me.
The Julia reveal. Yes, Julia didn't turn out evil in the anime. Yes, she died. Make it like the show, the purists demand. However, I think this could work as Season 2 needed some sort of continuity. It needed an arc. I can see that working.
Vicious still being a live. This could work too. Lot's could be made from his story line into Season 2.
Valentine coming to the rescue, that works for me.
I didn't like where how our 3 leads got left. And I don't think the resolution, which would have happened in Season 2, would not have been genuine. For a character like Jet, Spike's betrayal is not something that he would have forgiven. The endangering of his daughter is not something that Jet would forgive. Ever. There is no plausible way for the Writers to get out of that one.
I think it was a mistake to add Kimmie into the mix in the finale. Once she's endangered, even with a good outcome, I just can't see a guy like Jet being ok with that. And being ok with that is the only way to keep the story going so it's just not true to the character. For that, a major bomb on the writers.
That being said, the writers were able to capture the essence of the characters, but part of good writing is putting those characters in the right circumstances for a good story. The circumstances here just didn't work towards a good story. The "feel" of this ending is all off, and too broken.
Faye's leaving to find out about her past is true to the anime character. She is inherently selfish. However her wanting to side with Spike ONE EPISODE PRIOR is not. And now she's leaving? That's a bit inconsistent.
Everything Jet does here is true to character. And also kudos to Mustafa Shakir because he nailed this role to the T.
Spike is true to character. Julia is his weakness and it "feels" right that she'd be the one to shoot him.
What didn't feel right was the fracturing of the relationship by having Spike be the one that screws it up. And to screw it up in such a big way that hits Jet right in the heart. That whole ending just didn't feel like Bebop.
Also, I am extremely skeptical that a real life Ed would work. I just can't see that happening. The character is too loud, too zany for the noir feel of the show, and it's also a little creepy in real life. Ed does NOT translate well to live action, and I don't see how the writers could have ever pulled that off in Season 2.
And using Ed as the hook into the next season is not significant enough. It is improbably how that could lead to bridging the gang back together.
The finale of such an experiment should be a bit more triumphant. It needs to leave the audience with a good feeling so that we'd want to come back for a Season 2. The "feel" of this ending is all wrong. This feels more like a Season 2 type of finale. Such a shame because it was doing so well up to the last 5 minutes.
I can see the purists not liking this because there is quite a departure from the show. However, that isn't what didn't work for me. It was a lot darker than it needed to be and the hook wasn't as hopeful.
Firstly what worked, at least for me.
The Julia reveal. Yes, Julia didn't turn out evil in the anime. Yes, she died. Make it like the show, the purists demand. However, I think this could work as Season 2 needed some sort of continuity. It needed an arc. I can see that working.
Vicious still being a live. This could work too. Lot's could be made from his story line into Season 2.
Valentine coming to the rescue, that works for me.
I didn't like where how our 3 leads got left. And I don't think the resolution, which would have happened in Season 2, would not have been genuine. For a character like Jet, Spike's betrayal is not something that he would have forgiven. The endangering of his daughter is not something that Jet would forgive. Ever. There is no plausible way for the Writers to get out of that one.
I think it was a mistake to add Kimmie into the mix in the finale. Once she's endangered, even with a good outcome, I just can't see a guy like Jet being ok with that. And being ok with that is the only way to keep the story going so it's just not true to the character. For that, a major bomb on the writers.
That being said, the writers were able to capture the essence of the characters, but part of good writing is putting those characters in the right circumstances for a good story. The circumstances here just didn't work towards a good story. The "feel" of this ending is all off, and too broken.
Faye's leaving to find out about her past is true to the anime character. She is inherently selfish. However her wanting to side with Spike ONE EPISODE PRIOR is not. And now she's leaving? That's a bit inconsistent.
Everything Jet does here is true to character. And also kudos to Mustafa Shakir because he nailed this role to the T.
Spike is true to character. Julia is his weakness and it "feels" right that she'd be the one to shoot him.
What didn't feel right was the fracturing of the relationship by having Spike be the one that screws it up. And to screw it up in such a big way that hits Jet right in the heart. That whole ending just didn't feel like Bebop.
Also, I am extremely skeptical that a real life Ed would work. I just can't see that happening. The character is too loud, too zany for the noir feel of the show, and it's also a little creepy in real life. Ed does NOT translate well to live action, and I don't see how the writers could have ever pulled that off in Season 2.
And using Ed as the hook into the next season is not significant enough. It is improbably how that could lead to bridging the gang back together.
The finale of such an experiment should be a bit more triumphant. It needs to leave the audience with a good feeling so that we'd want to come back for a Season 2. The "feel" of this ending is all wrong. This feels more like a Season 2 type of finale. Such a shame because it was doing so well up to the last 5 minutes.