"Detective Montalbano" Un diario del '43 (TV Episode 2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A Diary from '43
Tweekums9 June 2019
As this episode opens preparations are being made to demolish two war time bunkers. People clearing the bunkers discover an old diary. It was written by a fifteen year old who was furious that the fascist regime had been overthrown and Sicily occupied by American forces. It spoke of how he planned to do something about it then suddenly stopped. Shortly afterwards a man in his nineties is shot by an assailant using a wartime pistol and ammunition; Salvo speculates that the killing might be linked to the events mentioned in the diary. In order to discover the identity of the recent murderer he will have to uncover what happened in 1943. Away from the case the police learn that pathologist Dr Pasquano has died and Salvo meets an American who was born in Vigàta but hadn't been back since being taken prisoner by the Americans during the war.

This was another really solid episode. The identity of the killer isn't too hard to guess but there are other suspects and the discovery of the motives is enjoyable as is the mystery of what happened in 1943. While the series rarely features action sequences this action does provide moments of threat and some scenes, during a flashback to 1943 that might disturb some viewers. The loss of Dr Pasquano, following the death of actor Marcello Perracchio, was handled in a suitably poignant way. The cast are all on fine form, both regulars and guest stars and as usual everything looks good... especially if you are watching in a rainy UK! Overall a fine episode; I hope we don't have to wait too long for this series to return.

These comments are based on watching the episode in Italian with English subtitles.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Soprano fans..yes it's Uncle Junior
phlbrq5812 October 2019
Solid ep featuring Dominic Chianese as a visiting American. His dialog is dubbed by a Sicilian actor but still boasts his screen presence. I love the series in general and was happy to see Dominic guesting here.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Entertaining if slow.
johnrgreen16 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
You know what you are going to get with Montelbano.red herrings or possible red herrings.coincidences.Like the American.or some distinguished gent who walks past his beautifully appointed home by the sea.of course Monte having respectful manners befriends them.they may play a handy part in the plot or add intellectual heft by quoting Montaigne or such like. Catarella,a buffoon or Malaprop.wearing tropes like the door entry and saying" personally .in person "when he has a visitor. Mimi,another buffoon.the joke is that he has bedded half the women around but is an incompetent cop whose theories are always wrong. Fazio is M s dependable side kick and like Radar O'Reilly anticipates plot developments.He always keeps vital information on pieces of paper.this annoys M. Then there's the girlfriend Livia who visits him from the North and who always gets abandoned the minute there's a sniff of a new case.M hides a Swedish would be mistress from her.M is irresistible to the femme fatales who emerge improbably from sleepy towns wearing red lippy and showing plenty of decolletage. He has a relationship with the local tv station and it's maverick owner.if there's a need he will be interviewed by him. There's an ogre of a man who performs medical examinations but is reluctant to give him any information.Also a glutton. M himself likes to eat alone and is a good snob.His housekeeper cooks amazing food apparently but Livia doesnt. He cracks the cases between mealtimes and by brilliant deductions it is full of echoing Italian interiors like his office where he grills various minor characters. It has great titles music and yes is entertaining but is quite long.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Montalbano at his best
DoctorStrabismus9 December 2023
An exceptionally slow-paced episode, which only serves to make it all the more gripping as the story so slowly unwinds.

As its title makes clear, it is dealing with events from wartime, and how they somehow manage to resurface more than seven decades later, with all manner of implications for those still surviving from that era. The flashbacks to then are extremely powerful, and very well played-out.

Luca Zingaretti delivers an absolute masterclass performance as Salvo, and often the less he says, the more he tells us with his expressions and actions.

And a most moving farewell is made for Dottor Pasquano, following the death of actor Marcello Perracchio, with all the central characters making an absolutely fitting silent tribute to him.

We were held enthralled throughout, and this could not be scored at anything less than 10/10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed